The Great Migration of 1971 III Return

Please download to get full document.

View again

of 4
6 views
PDF
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Document Description
The Great Migration of 1971: III: Return Author(s): Partha N. Mukherji Reviewed work(s): Source: Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 9, No. 11 (Mar. 16, 1974), pp. 449-451 Published by: Economic and Political Weekly Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/4363497 . Accessed: 28/11/2011 03:44 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps s
Document Share
Documents Related
Document Tags
Document Transcript
  The Great Migration of 1971: III: ReturnAuthor(s): Partha N. MukherjiReviewed work(s):Source: Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 9, No. 11 (Mar. 16, 1974), pp. 449-451Published by: Economic and Political Weekly Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/4363497. Accessed: 28/11/2011 03:44 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jspJSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new formsof scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.  Economic and Political Weekly is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to  Economic and Political Weekly. http://www.jstor.org  The Great Migration of 1971 III-Return ParthaNMukherji This is anexploratorytudy oftheevacuees wholeftEastBengalaftertheimposition ofmartiallaw on March25,1971,andsought refugein India.Accordingtoofficialstatistics, bythe secondweekofDecember 1971 about6.8million evacueeshadbeen housed incampsand another3.1millionwerestayingwithfriendsandrelatives.Asmanyas 827 statecampsand19 Centralcampsaccommodatedoneof the largestmigrantmovementsinhistory.This three-partstudyconcentratesonthosewho weretemporarily settledatthe ChandparaandBokchora campsinthedistrict of 24-ParganasnWestBengal.PartIlllooks at themigrationofthe eva-cueesbacktoBangladeshandthe manner nwhich itwasachieved.It alsodiscussessometheoreticalformulationsregardingtherefugees.PartIIhadexaminedtheorganisationalset-upof thecamps, therelationsbetweenhostsand guestsinandaroundthecamps and theadoptivecapacities of theevacuees intheir newenvironment.PartIhaddealtwith the socio-ecotnomicbackgrotund oftheevacuees, the eventsleadingtotheir uprootmentand thetrek tosanctuary. WEhave observedthecircumstancesunider whiclhtheexodustookplacefromtw-o regions of EastBengal.WVehavealso examined the pattern of resettle-mentand socialinteractionin India be- t\ween thehostsystemnandtheguests.Itisof considerable interesttostuidy,even thoughbriefly,thereturn oftheevacueestoanindependentBangladeshafterthe victoryof theIndo-Bangla-desharmedforces.Almost immediately afterthecessa-tion ofhostilities thereNwasmuchmo-vement backand forth acrossthebor-der. Withinaperiodof less than twoweeks several small groupsfromeachofthetwocampshadgoneintoBan-gladesh,madeaquick survey oftheconditionsin theirregionsandreport-edbacktothecamps.Theirreportsweresurprisinglyuniform.ThesegroupswereaccordedaredcarpetwelcomebytheirBengaliMuslimneighbours,-whoshowed considerablesympathyforthemandeagerly enquired abouttheirconditions acrosstheborder.Theneigh-boursassuredthem thatthepropertyof the evacuieeswas safe, thatis,theirlandedproperty.These'explorer'grouLps also found evidence of theMuktiBahini taking strongretaliatorymeasuresagainst betrayersof theBangladesh nationalistmovement. ManyRazakars and influentialmembers ofPeaceCommittees werereported tohavebeenkilled; the MuktiBahini waspoisedtoclispense rough andreadyjustice.Withastonishing rapiditythe eva-cuee also came to know aboutthe ex-tentofdamage to his houseand pro-perty, the chances of recoveryof hislooted goods and many other minutedetails of information in whichhe wasinterested. All these werefurther fa-cilitatedljyfrequent visits ofthe Ben-gali Muslim neighboursfromacrosstheborderwhowereequallycurioustosee'how their Hindu neighbourshadfaredduringthenine monthperiod.The increased interactions acrosstheborder coupled with the gloryofthevictoriousoperationsbyIndianarmyand the MuktiBahinigeneratedanun-mistakable urgefortheevacuees tore-turnto their native country.Theemer-genceofBangladeshviewedas com-pletely free ;fmomtheoppresslionsofPakistan presentedasolutiontotheirproblems.Incomparisonto thepros-pectsof a free lifeina newly indepen-(lent country, camp life appeared tobelikea bondagexvhichhadsuddenlybecomeintolerable.Theimpatiencewith which theyawaitedreleasefromthe campswasnotable.Anotherfactorwhichmadethemfeelrestless togowasthe approaching(leadline forthenext sowingofpaddywhichhadtobedone preferably by January15.It is truethat theywerealso con-cerned abouttheuncertainties of shel-ter and food in their own land. Butthe urge to return was unmistakablystronger and the assurances made bythe Indian and Bangladesh governmentsto provide all that they could to re-settle themhadtheexpected impact.Itwasutterlyfascinatingto see in-numerable truck- and train-loads of eva-cuees returning homewvithjoyousshouts of Joi Bangla (Victory toBangladesh). I had the privilege oftravelling with a group on a truck toJessorefrom where Iwventto a villageonthe outskirts of ChchianobboiGramand stayed for nearly a week.The reception in Jessore district hadacquired a procedural system. Collegeteachers and students in the townsandschool teachers and volunteers in thevillageswerereceivingevacueesattheircentresandcanalisingthem totheirrespectivedestinations.Usuallyatsuchcentrestherewas provisionforrationsandfor anovernighthalt forthose intransit.Theentire civilad-m-iinistrationeemed tobe alivetotheneedforsolvingthisalmostunmanage-ableproblem.Allavailable busesandtruckswereceaselesslyengagedintransportationof theevacuees.ButtheinitialenthusiasmwithwvhichheevacueesleftIndiaand withwhichtheyreachedtheirhomesdidnotrequliremuchtimeto beeroded.Faced withtherealityofdestroyed andvacanthomes,thereturnee wasimme-diatelyfaced withasituationwhoseimplicationshehadnotbeenabletocalculatefaraway fromnhome.Thedestructionofhousescouldbroadly beclassifiedintothreecategories:housesw-ithrooftopsandwallsbutpracticallynothingelse,houseswithcompletelyburntoutrootswithjustthe wallsstanding,andcompletelyguttedhou-ses. Ofthethreecategories,these-condpredominatedinthevillagesIsaw.Some ofthereturneesIcouldseehadmanagedtoputaroofofsortsoverone oftheirroomsand sostartanewlifeintheirownhomes.Thepatternofrecovery ofgoods isextremelyinteresting. itwascertainlvnotuniforminallregions.Ishallthereforeconfinemyselftothevillagew-here Istayedand towhat Isawdu-ringa20-miletrip onabicycle.Theprocess ofrecoverywasinitiatedbyappealsfromtheMuktiBahini com-miiandtationedinthevillageandafewdynamicMuslimneaders.The si-tuLationwasextremelyembarrassing andparadoxical.Forthe'custodians'ofsuchgoodstoopenlyreturnthem totheirrightfulownerswas toacknow-449  March 16, 1974ECONOMIC AND POLITICALWEEKLYledgehavingplayedahighlydeviantrole.At thesametimetheircollectiveroleinthismatterwasnosecrettoanybody.Thispresentedaproblemeven forthosewhohadhadnointen-tionof enjoyingtheir destituteneigh-bours'goods.Facedwiththiskindof predica-mentsomerespondedtothe appealanddepositedthegoodswiththe MuktiBahinicommand.A few returnedthemdirectlytotheownerstryingtheirbestto explainaway or just keepquietastowhy theyhadtakenthem.Therewereotherswhoshowedreluctancetorespondto theappeal.However,thereturneeswereableto identifyand getinformationaboutthewhereaboutsoftheir goodswithremarkablespeedandaccuracy.Thiswas only possiblebe-causeof theco-operationof theirMus-limsneighbourswhowere tryingtomakeamendsfortheir conduct.Pur-suingsuchinformationthereturneewouldsendamessage, generallyindi-rectly,tothecustodianofhisgoodsandrequesthim to returnit.Ifthecustodianfailedtorespond,acom-plaintwouldbelodgedwiththe MuktiBahinicommand,whichwouldexpedi-tiouslyinvestigateandrecoverthegoods.In a neighbouringvillage,theMuktiBahinihad demarcatedanareawherethe custodiansofothers'goodswerere-questedtodumpthemand thereturneeswererequestedtoidentifytheir proper-tyandtakeithome.Thiswas sup-posedtoavoida lotofembarrassmentfor boththecustodiansandthere-turnees,.Thisdemarcatedareawaslitteredwithallkinds of thingsbeds,almirahs,doorsandwindows,woodenbeams,etc.This proceduremetwithreasonablesuccessastheex-tentof recoverywas placedroughlyat30percentwhichwasconsidered goodwithinthattime span.Inothervillages,cartloadsofgoodsbeingtakenfrom a custodian'shousetoa returnee'shousewerenotanin-frequentsight.However,thispatternwas notfollowedinsomevillagesinthe predominantlyHindupopulatedareas.TheHindushavingreturnedtotheir srcinalstrongholdswereforce-fullydemandingbacktheirgoodsfromtheir Muslimneighbours.Inatleastonevillageanold Muslimwasliterallyintearsdescribinghow inspiteof hisbesteffortsin helpingrecoverthe loot-edgoodshe wasbeinginsultedandabused.Hecomplainedthat oneofthe returneeshad pluckeedhis beardandonanother occasionhischildwas slap-pedandtoldthathis fatherwasalowN-downooter.ThisoldMuslimfrankly expressedfear thathis lifewasnot safe and he was thinking of mov-ingtosomeotherplace.In thiscontextit hastobenotedthattheMuktiBahiniwas notoperat-inginthisareaandtherewasnoef-fectivealternativemechanismn ortheresolutionofsuchproblems.Thisin-dicatesthat the MuktiBabini,in theabsenceofanyof theinstitutionsoflawandorder,served as avery impor-tantagency ofsocial control.And sotheMukti Bahini'sabsencefromanarea generated tensions.In a sensethe Mukti Bahini, symbo-lised asliberatorsofthecountry,wasplaying a role which even normal in-stitutionsofsocialcontrolNerepre-sumablynotina position toplay.Clear evidence ofthiscouldbe seensoon after the Prime Minister of Ban-gladesh appealed totheMukti Bahinito laydownarms voluntarily andde-clared that those whodidnotheed theappealwouldbe identified or labelledas Al Badrs (the infamousmaskedgroup which engagedinthe massslaughterof intellectuals onthe eve oftheliberation of Bangladesh). Therole of the Mukti Bahini then imme-diately received a check and the vo-luntary return of goods from custo-diansregisteredasharpdecline. Thisshows thestatusandpower theMuktiBahinienjoyedinthe village cornmuni-tywhere Isawitoperate. TOWARDSATHEORETICALINTEGRATION Thisexploratory study raises cer-taintheoretical problems. One mightposethemainquestion very general-ly:Whatisthesocialresponse tocri-ses?Certainly,therearelikelytobevarieties of responses justasone canidentifyavarietyof crises.The socialresponse to crises emanating from na-turalcauses is likely tobevastly diffe- rent from crises emanating from socialandpolitical causes.Thusacommu-nity may face challenges from earth-quakes, floods,tidal wavesor tornadoes-crisiswhichhavebeenlbetterlabel-ledasdisasters. It can also face a cri-sis ofanextremely different nature-wherethecrisisis notoverwiththedisaster, but in fact is a continuing one.Intheformer type of crisis, thecom-unimity mobilisesitsresources to makeupfor the losses. Ifthecommunity isin an earthquake zone or tornado-prone area, it develops certain mechan-ismsbywhichit can face the recurrence of suchcrises and their aftermath. Thelattertypeofcrises, in which completeuprootment of a very large groupfrom its soil to an alien country is the mostextremeform, isdistinctive inthatthe causal generating factor being socio-politicalis much morecomplexand forthe uprooted people there is no fami-liarprecedent to fallbackupon.Uprootedfromnhis nativesoil,tornfrom his national identity, theeva-cuee is forced toacceptanunstable,uincertain future for himselfand hisfamily.Theexperiencesofpost-warrefugees haveshownthatneurosis isa conimon conditionamiionghemand quite apartfromsymptomsofa de-finitely pathologicalcharacter, thereisevery justification forspeakingofa'refugee complex'. '0It would beex-pected that anidlegroup,forcedintoapathy, would manifest serioussyirlm- tonms of personaldisorganisation.Butthis was not so among the refugees Iwaswith. As indicated earlier, neitherthe doctor visiting the two camps nor the camp inmatesreported a singlecase ofhysteria orany abnormal be-haviour. There were many persons re-porting how shattered their nerves wereonaccount oftheirshocking experi-ences in East Pakistan,butthey di(dnot show any signs of neurosis. What,therefore, explains thesocialandpsy-chological stabilityof this groupinsuch circumstances?One may infer that either the causesofsuchtension were successfully re-solvedor thatatension-managementmechanism hadcomeinto operationwhich,inspiteofthecontinuingtenseobjective situation,neverthelesshelpedto retain the balance of the individual.Itisclear thatbydenyingthethernEast Pakistannationals Indian co-na-tionality and by imposing Onthemaforcedidleness, thesituationtheeva-cueeswere placedinwrasconducivetoproblemsofpersonaldisorganisationi.In thiscontext,threeprocessescanbeidentifiedwhichperformedhe allimpor-tantfunctionoftension-management.They are: (a)thereactivationoftheevacuees'ruralcommunitystructures;(b)theemergenceofthe campcom-munityon a modelclosetothatofthevillage; (c)deviant behaviour whichacted asa safetyvalve. The first twoprocesses (especially the first) enabledtheindividualto retainor regainhisidentity in theinstitutionalised systemofstatus androleinwhichhehadope-rated. If theevacuee had lost hisstatusvi.s-a-vis thesocial environmentaround him, he stillretained his socialpositioninthesystemof social inter-actionandsocialsolidarity. The indi-vidualevacuee wasnot suffering in iso-lation torn out of his group. Theen- 450  ECONOMICAND POLITICALWEEKLYMarch16,1974 tirecollectivitywassharingacrisisthe challengewas not facedonlybytheindividualbutbytheentiregroup.HereonemightrefertotheDur-kheimnianhypothesiswhichpositsthatanincreaseintheintegrationofagroup'whichfacesacrisiscausesareduc-tion intherate ofegotistic suicides.Durkheim statesthat greatsocialdis- tLrbances andpopular warsrousecol-lectivesentiments,stimulatepartisanspiritandpatriotism,politicalandna-tionalfaith,alike, andconcentratingactivitytoward asingleend,atleasttemporarilycauseastrongerintegra-tionofsociety .11Thisprompts himtopostulatethat Suicidevariesinver-selywiththedegreeofintegrationofpoliticalsociety. '2Withapermis-sibleextensionofthishypothesisonecanseeintheinstanceoftheBangla-deshevacueesthereactivatedmechani-calsolidarityfunctioningasatension-managementmechanismandminimisingtheoccurrenceofneurosisandpersonalclisorganisation.Thetheoreticalirnplicationsofthesafety-valvemechanismofthedevi-antinfrastructuresarefarfromsuper-ficial.Whilethesocialsystemofthecommunitywastransferredacrosstheborderand newcampcommunitiesemerged, itfounditselfoperatingorexistinginaneconomicvacuum.Thisraisesthefollowingproblem:Whathappenstoasocial systemwhichhasasocialstructurebut whichsuddenlyisfaced with the lossofitseconomicsubsystem?Therecouldbe threepos-sibleresults;(1)the socialsystemmaydissolve itselfintoanothersocio-cultu-ralsystemandgetintegratedwith theeconomicsystem ofthelatter; (2) thesocialsystemwillgenerateanewitsowneconomicsubsvstem;(.3)the socialsystemwillfaceseriousproblems ofdisorganisationandperish,ifitisnot in apositionforpossibilities(1)and/or(2).In thepresentcontext,possibility(1)couldhaveresultedfromgrantingco-nationality andrehabilitatingtheeva-cuee.This theevacuee waslegallyde-nied.Possibility (2)wasalsolegallydenied.Thethirdpossibilitywastheonewhichtheevacuee wasforced toaccept, withthedifferencethatthephysicalsurvivalandsecurityoftheevacueewasensured. Insucha situa-tion, theinstitutionalisedandemergingsocialstructuresgeneratedtheirowndevianteconomicinfrastructurestocompensate forthelosteconomic sub-system.Thisstudy,therefore,providesanimportantinsightintotheunderstand-ingoftheprimacy oftheeconomicsulbsystemfor thesurvival ofasocialsystem and its individualmembers.The superstructureswere'compelled'togenerate a baseofeconomicactivity,without which thesocialsystemwasthreatened withpossibledisaster.Asforthespeedydepartureoftheevacueesfromthecamps,there wereimportant'pull' and'push'factorswhichexpedited it.Once thesrcinalcausalgeneratingfactoridentifiedwiththecrisiswassatisfactorilyremoved,thesocialsystems withtheirfragmentedecologicalbasestrovetoregain theirecologicalunity.Theguests'unequalrelationship wviththeirhosts - withaverticalone-way movementofobliga-tionsdefining alowstatusfortheevacuees in thestratificationscheme - wvas aklind ofanl 'oppression'charac-terisedbyseveredeprivation,restric-tionsandhumiliations.TheliberationofBangladeshprovided anopportunityto'liberate'oneselffromthis low-statuspositionand toregainone's statusin one'sowntotalsocialsetting. Notes 10JacquesVernant, TheRefugeein thePost-WarWorld ,GeorgeAllenandUnwin,London,1953.11EmileDurkheim, Suicide (trans-latedbyJASpaulding andGeorgeSwipson), Routledge andKeganPaul,London, 1953,p 208.12Ibid,p208. FROMTHECHAIR Aibright, Morarji and Pandit Limited SpeechoftheChairman,ShriNDandeker,ICS(Retd) THEfollowingis theSpeechdeliveredby ShriNDandeker,ICS(Retd),Chairman,Albright,MorarjiandPanditLimited, attheEighthAnnualGeneralMeetingoftheMembersheldon Wed-nesday,March6,1974: LADIESANDGENTLEMEN, Ihavegreatpleasure inwelcomingyoutothisEIGHTHANNUAL GENE-RALMEETING.TheAuditedStatementsofAccountfortheyearended 31stOctober,1973,and theDirectors'Reportthereonhavebeenwithyouforsometimenow.Withyourpermission,Ishalltakethemasread.Theresultsoftheyear'soperationshavebeenverydisappointingindeed,comparedwiththoseofthepreviousyear.Thereweretwoprincipalreasonsforthis.Firstly,there weresharpincreasesin allcosts.RockPhosphatewhichis themajor rawmaterialfortheCompany'sproductionisimportedfromMorocco;andbecauseoftheverytightfreightmarketandthecongestionintheBom-bayDocks,thefreightonshipmentshasbeensky-rocketing.Theotherimportantrawmaterial,namelySodaAsh,beinggreatlyinshortsupplytheCompanyhadtoimportsomeofitsrequirementatapriceverymuchhigherthanthatofindigenousSodaAsh.Therehasalsobeencontinuingincreaseinthecostofpower,furnaceoil,keroseneoilandengineeringstores.Inaddition, someadhocbenefits badtobegrantedtotheCompany's em-ployees.Intheresult.thecostofgoodsproducedby theCompanyasreflectedintheAccounts isdispropor-tionatelyhigherthanthecorresponcl-ingcostinthepreviousyear.Never-theless,yourBoard quiterightly thoughtitproperthattheCompanyshouldforsometimeendeavourtoabsorbthese costincreasesinsteadofpassingthemontoourcustomers.Secondly,even whiletheCompanywasthusmakingeveryefforttoholdthe pricelinewhilemaximising produc-tionto meettheever-increasingdemandsfromthemanufacturers ofnon-soapydetergentsandalso otherusersofSodiumTripolyphosphate, theworkersstruckworkforeightdaysinAprilandindulged inaprolonged sit-in strikefrom12thOctober,raising cer-tainwhollyillegalanduntenabledemands.Thisstrikecontinuedintothecurrentaccounting yearuntil, final-ly, themanagementwasreluctantlycompelledto declareapartialclosureofthecompany's plantfrom 3rdDecem-I)er1973.Work atthefactorywasfinallyresumedonlyon30thDecember 1973.451
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks